Cartography: Map Critique

    What's important in a map? 

    Maps play an important role in presenting information. Maps has many parts that come together to present/ represent the data within the map. Some parts of a map are the Title, North Arrow (orientation), Scale Bar, Data Source (citing source), and a Legend (to identify symbology and map features). 

Good Map Designs

    Good map designs always has a Title to them. Sub-titles can be used to elaborate or close in on the topic of the map to help direct the reader's attention to the map details. In the map below, the designer provided a nice Title, but utilized subtitles and short summary to give the readers clarity to what the map wants to present to it's audience. Another important aspect of a good designed map is map layout. This map maintain a balanced presentation with clear borderlines and placed in strategic positions that didn't distract the reader from the main map. 


Poorly Design Map

      One main factor to a poorly designed map is how the map is laid out and the choice of designs used for representing map features. For example, in the map below three major issues with this map is: (1) how the legend is very unclear, (2) overcrowding of map information (labels of features), and (3) no data source citation. Without these aspects, the map can cause confusion and the intention of the map designer doesn't come across to the audience. Improvements that can help this map can be adding a clear Title to announce the map's purpose. Organizing the legend's position and properly account all the symbology to help readers identify key map features. Lastly, sort display substantial information that would help highlight the map's purpose to the audience, but also remove unnecessary information that may conflict with the main idea. Remember, a good map requires forethought and planning. 





Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Fundamentals in Python

Image
  Flowchart Working with Spyder was a challenge. I had started on step 1 on a different approach than the lab instructions gave. My First Attempt started as follows stringName = “Brittany Anne Joe”  nameList – (“Brittany” “Anne” “Joe”)  print (“Joe”)  Although this gave the same results of printing my last name Joe in the program I learned to use some of Python’s functions that allows me to print my last name from a list. stringName.split automatically takes your stringName feature and divide it into separate cars for “Brittany” “Anne” “Joe”. To specify what to print from a list you need to index by specifying the number that represents your list. So “Brittany” would be 0, “Anne “would be 1, and “Joe” was 2.  After step 1, we had to debug a prewritten code that generates the results of random wins and losses for the players. I was challenged to create a loop to generate 20 random numbers between 0-10. My unlucky value was number 5 and we had to use an if/else statement to count the num
Read more

Module 5: Choropleth and Proportional Mapping

Image
 This week's assignment challenges us to explore data sets and using graduated and proportional symbology to present data. Graduated symbology utilizes classified data that shows the quantitative differences between data in which data is classified in ranges and a different sized symbol represents that range. Proportional symbology uses unclassified data to represent values in a field using the attribute value.  One challenge in this week's lab was working on the symbology by inputting a picture symbol into the mapping project. Another challenge to the week's lab is adjusting the European country's labels. Due to the close proximity of some countries or the size of the country the label wouldn't fit inside. Many adjustments were made, but there can be further improvements in future projects. 
Read more

Module 3: Cartographic Design

Image
 Gestalt's Principles   In our week's lesson, we learned about Gestalt's Principles covers cartographic design techniques that allows the audience to better understand a map. Few points about cartographic design and how gestalt's principles apply to map design is understanding the four techniques to display data.  Visual Heirachy Using symbols and ranking methodology to highlight data importance or where you want your audience to focus on in map. You can make single symbols different sizes to represent different classes or highlight their value on the map compared to other data such as population maps.  Contrast  Contrast focuses on differences between map features such as adjustments to size, color, or shape. Sometimes certain color choices such as blues and reds are great for highway and interstates. It can be helpful with a neutral background.  Balance  Balance is the organization of all map elements that fills the space granted for the map project, but use empty spa
Read more